Question:
Does anybody ever recall seeing a spanking scene in a film?
dinksdalton
2009-03-04 04:02:31 UTC
People who believe spanking is too violent must believe 'The Sound of Music' is too violent as there is a spanking scene in that.
Twelve answers:
Fright Film Fan
2009-03-04 04:09:03 UTC
...what about the scene in 1984's "All of Me", where Steve Martin's character is possessed by the ghost of Lily Tomlin's character, and through him, she spanks the butt of Victoria Tennent's character?? Very weird, but not necessarily violent.....
MystMoonstruck
2009-03-04 13:54:30 UTC
The Bad Seed~At the end of the film, Patty McCormack is spanked because Rhoda has been such a bad girl. Basically, this was the Fifties, when a film about a murderous child would make people nervous, so they added this as a humorous(?) touch.



If I recall correctly, there are on-screen spankings in:

The Quiet Man~Doesn't John Wayne swat Maureen O'Hara? Later, the two battle, ending up in a famous scene in "McLintock!" (already listed).

Taming of the Shrew~various versions

Tom Brown's School Days (1940)

Careful, He Might Hear You

The Night of the Hunter

Yankee Doodle Dandy

The Seven Little Foys

A Home of Our Own

Exit to Eden *blush*

The Children's Hour

The Whipping Boy

Casey's Shadow

Kiss Me, Kate!

Barry Lyndon

Mrs. Miniver



In "The Curse of the Cat People", it occurs off-screen, when Amy refuses to say that Irena is an imaginary friend.



There are more films of people, especially children, being beaten with a cane, belt or strop in many period films. (A strop is the leather strip used for sharpening a razor for shaving.) Now, THAT is violent! Those include:

Lady Jane~Jane (Helena Bonham Carter) is beaten into submission by her mother in a harrowing, lengthy scene.

Wuthering Heights~both versions(?)

How Green Was My Valley

The Fool Killer

Pretty Baby



I have severe pain syndromes, so I especially remember such moments of physical distress during which I often mute the sound of simply close my eyes. As a child of the Fifties and being exceptionally stubborn, I also recall being spanked!
anonymous
2009-03-04 12:06:50 UTC
Along Came Polly
anonymous
2009-03-04 12:07:02 UTC
A kid gets a spanking from Nicole Kidman in Dogville
Brandon Ros
2009-03-04 12:17:41 UTC
RocknRolla, it is implied that the boy is beat with a belt after disobeying his father. It is not actually shown.



Step Brothers, a joke spank?
anonymous
2009-03-04 12:10:31 UTC
Tom Brown's schooldays.
Rosiepop
2009-03-04 12:23:03 UTC
Pollyanna

Secretary
Kerry K
2009-03-04 12:08:01 UTC
Secretary

rooster coglan

doctors at large

McLintock
maka
2009-03-04 12:10:52 UTC
Wasnt the King and I one as well
rustyham99
2009-03-04 12:12:23 UTC
john wayne, in mcclintock. two seens one with steph powers.
stickywicket36
2009-03-04 12:13:34 UTC
the secretary
D R U M S ™
2009-03-04 12:09:56 UTC
"Driving Miss Daisy"

Starring me and your mother.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...