Question:
What parts of Star Trek was the movie based on?
STU
2009-05-16 22:51:05 UTC
Was the movie based on the entire series or just a small portion of the show?
Four answers:
Stainless Steel Rat
2009-05-16 22:55:25 UTC
No. None of it is based on the show. It takes place in an alternate universe and the events happen before the five year mission.
Jaycee
2009-05-24 17:09:35 UTC
Star Trek XI had several similarities to the motion picture film Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan and the original series episode "This Side of Paradise." The trouble is that it plagiarizes both episodes but doesn't extrapolate on either. There are time travel elements in the film, but they don't resemble the original series. In the original Star Trek, time travel was achieved by traveling at warp speed around a star. In the new movie it's acheived by something called "red matter," which creates a black hole.



Furthermore, Star Trek XI departs from canon too much to be truly based on canon. Captain Christopher Pike is about ten years older than he should be, the Enterprise is brand new (it should be at least 6 years old at this point in the Star Trek history) and has undergone a shocking redesign, so that it looks more advanced even than later episodes in the franchise, such as the Star Trek motion picture series and the Voyager series. Several people attend Starfleet Academy together despite drastic differences in their ages and the Enterprise leaves space dock on its maiden voyage with a crew full of cadets.



Spock makes out with Uhura and attacks Kirk on the bridge in full view of the crew, things that would never have happened in the original Star Trek series. Kirk is too flaky and hits on Uhura, another thing that would never happen. Also, in the Star Trek canon, Kirk served on board the USS Farragut and the USS Republic prior to becoming captain of the Enterprise. In the new Star Trek movie, he goes from delinquency at Starfleet Academy to first officer and then captain of the Enterprise so fast it'll make your head spin.



You can learn more about the Star Trek series and the new movie here:



http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/1736180/star_trek_xi_movie_review.html
washburnhoban
2009-05-17 05:57:04 UTC
Actually it was based on the entire series and canon of the universe.



As a time travel reboot it can maintain the canon that what happened before did happen but now it may happen again and only differently.



(Read : the old Spock is your answer here... he can recite everything he and the original crew did. He now lives in the past though in a new timeline where his planet is dead, his mother gone and approximately 10000 Vulcans are all that's left...)
anonymous
2009-05-17 05:58:54 UTC
This is the prequel with a twist on thing will turn out on the future if you havent seen it i sujest going its a great star trek movie risky but pays off 110%


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...